Tracking error and the information ratio

From Chapter 7 of The Analyst's Handbook, by Matt Lang and Bree Lang

Imagine two funds that both beat their benchmark by 2.0 points last year. The first one moved more or less with the benchmark all year and finished a little ahead. The second one spent the year far above the benchmark in some months and far below it in others, and happened to end in the same place. Both funds will report the same active return, so we need another measure to tell them apart.

That measure is called the tracking error (TE). On each day we subtract the benchmark's return from the fund's return, which gives us a series of daily active returns. The tracking error is the standard deviation of that series, scaled up to a year:

TE = stdev(r_p − r_b) × √252

Suppose that the daily active returns of a fund have a standard deviation of 0.1889%. Multiplying by the square root of 252 (which is 15.8745) gives a tracking error of 3.00% a year. In other words, in a typical year this fund should be expected to land within about three points of its benchmark in either direction.

The tracking error tells us how far a fund strayed, and the information ratio (IR) tells us whether the straying was worth it:

IR = Active Return / TE

Both numbers are annualized. Say that our first fund had a tracking error of about 6%, so its information ratio is 2.0 / 6 = 0.33. The second fund carried the same 2.0 points home through about 9% of tracking error, so its information ratio is 2.0 / 9 = 0.22. The funds won the same prize, but the second one wandered much farther from the benchmark to collect it. As a guide, a standard reference on active management calls an information ratio of 0.5 good, 0.75 very good and 1.0 exceptional.

A very low tracking error is not automatically good news. Imagine a third fund whose returns follow the index so closely that its tracking error is 0.5%. This fund has never had a bad quarter against its benchmark, but only because it never leaves the benchmark (a student who copies the answer key does not miss many questions either). A fund like this is called a closet indexer, because it charges for active management and delivers something very close to an index fund, and tracking error is the number that catches it.

Chapter 7 of the textbook builds both measures by hand from ten days of returns.

Read Chapter 7: Tracking error and information ratio

Related topics: Beta and alpha · The Sharpe ratio and the Sortino ratio · All topics

The Analyst's Handbook is Sifter's free textbook for student investors, written by Matt Lang and Bree Lang. Sifter is free for students. This page as markdown.