The Sharpe ratio and the Sortino ratio
From Chapter 5 of The Analyst's Handbook, by Matt Lang and Bree Lang
Imagine two student funds, which we will call Granite and Bottle Rocket, that both finished the year up 12.0%. Granite got there by gaining a little in most weeks. Bottle Rocket got there through a series of rallies and collapses that would make a reasonable treasurer consider another line of work. Take a moment and ask yourself whether the two funds had the same year.
On the bottom line they did, which means that the bottom line is leaving something out. The first number that recovers it is volatility, which is the standard deviation of a fund's daily returns multiplied by the square root of 252 (the number of trading days in a year). Granite's volatility for the year was 9%, and Bottle Rocket's was 24%.
The Sharpe ratio puts the return and the volatility into one figure. It asks how much return a fund earned above a risk-free investment for each point of volatility that it took on:
Sharpe = (R − Rf) / σ
Here R is the annualized return, Rf is the risk-free rate (what Treasury bills paid over the same period) and σ is the annualized volatility. With a risk-free rate of 5.3%, Granite has a Sharpe ratio of (12.0% − 5.3%) / 9% = 0.74, and Bottle Rocket has (12.0% − 5.3%) / 24% = 0.28. This means that Granite earned 0.74 points above Treasury bills for every point of volatility its members lived through, while Bottle Rocket earned 0.28 points for the same price.
As a rough guide, a Sharpe ratio below zero means that Treasury bills won, 0.5 is respectable, 1.0 is strong, and anything above 2.0 should be checked twice before it is repeated to anyone.
The president of Bottle Rocket has a fair objection at this point, which is that half of the fund's volatility was upward, and nobody has ever complained about a week that made 6%. The Sortino ratio was built to answer that objection. It keeps the same numerator and divides by the downside deviation (DD), which counts only the days that fell below the target:
Sortino = (R − Rf) / DD
Suppose that a fund has five daily returns of +2%, −1%, +3%, −2% and +1%. The standard deviation of those five days is 2.07%. For the downside deviation we square only the two losing days (which gives us 1 and 4), divide by all five days and take the square root, and the result is 1.00% a day. In other words, the same five days show 2.07% of movement in total and 1.00% of the kind that anybody minds.
A portfolio whose large moves are mostly upward will look much better on the Sortino ratio than on the Sharpe ratio, and a report that shows both lets the reader see which kind of volatility the fund had. Chapter 5 of the textbook builds both ratios from the two funds' daily returns.
Read Chapter 5: Volatility, Sharpe, Sortino, drawdown
Related topics: Maximum drawdown · Tracking error and the information ratio · All topics
The Analyst's Handbook is Sifter's free textbook for student investors, written by Matt Lang and Bree Lang. Sifter is free for students. This page as markdown.