# Price return and total return

*By Matt Lang and Bree Lang, authors of The Analyst's Handbook, Sifter's free textbook for student investors · https://sifter.finance/textbook/topics/price-return-and-total-return*

How do we know whether an investment did well? The starting point is the percentage change in its price over the time we held it:

```
Price return = ending price / starting price − 1
```

Apple closed at $347.73 on October 23, 2026. An investor who bought at the close on December 31, 2025, for $271.86 was up $347.73 / $271.86 − 1 = 27.9%. An investor who bought on April 8, 2025, at $172.42 was up 101.7%, which is a little more than double. Now imagine a third investor who bought on December 26, 2024, at $259.02 and sold on April 8, 2025, at that same $172.42. That investor lost 33.4%. All three owned the same company, which means that a return only makes sense when we know the two dates it covers.

A price return also leaves something out. Many companies pay dividends, and those payments are part of what an owner earned even though they never appear on a price chart. The return that includes them is called the total return, and it assumes that each dividend is used to buy more shares on the day it is paid.

Over short periods the difference can look too small to bother with, but it grows a lot over long ones. From December 30, 2005, to December 31, 2025, the price of SPY went from $124.51 to $681.92, which is about 5.48 times. With every dividend reinvested, the same investment grew about 7.93 times. This means that $1,000 became about $5,477 on price alone and about $7,934 with dividends, so a chart of the price would have left out about $2,457 of what the investor actually had.

Whenever you compare two returns, check that both are the same kind. A stock's price return placed next to a fund's total return makes the stock look worse than it was, and the same mistake in the other direction makes it look better. The reason that reinvested dividends add so much over twenty years is compounding, which is the next idea to look at.

The full textbook: https://sifter.finance/textbook
